Softwood Lumber duties “unfair”

Aug 14, 2024 | 2:11 PM

PRINCE GEORGE – Every year, BC lumber producers ship roughly $4 billion worth of lumber into the United States. But American producers have convinced the US Commerce Department to impose two forms of duties on BC: Countervailing and anti-dumping. The US argues the harvesting practices of Canadian producers constitute a subsidy. Hence the countervailing duties. Anti-dumping is different again.

“The anti-dumping duty is related more to the sort of allegation that Canada is selling its product in the US at a price that’s lower than what they’re selling into Canada or below the cost of production,” explains Kurt Niquidet, President of the BC Lumber Trade Council.

Canada has historically prevailed in this argument, but it is costing the industry a bundle, to the tune of $9 billion dollars held in deposit. But the latest round of duties is an average of 14.54%. And it couldn’t come at a worse time.

“B.C. has been facing a lot of challenges, particularly on the supply side with land use policies that have limited our access to fibre and our cost structure has gone up over time,” says Niquidet. “And then you combine that with weaker conditions more recently on the demand side, which is with high interest rates, that’s led to sort of kind of a weaker market.”

Industry advocates north of the 49th Parallel have long argued the tariffs affect American consumers in a big way, driving up the price of lumber in the States.

“The way this dispute has gone, though, is within the U.S. It seems like, even though that is a huge impact, I think some people have calculated that. It’s a massive impact to the United States as a whole. But it seems like the U.S. producer has their voice has triumphed in this.”

And the schedule to take the matter to appeal is a lengthy one.